[Coop] Upstairs Downstairs
Mapping Since May 21, 2011
It's not that far off from being an intended solution - I think it'd be permissible.
Co-operative: Lightspeed Upstairs Downstairs
Redunzl and I spent 2.5 hours banging our way through this one. Some of the most enjoyable hours we've spent playing together. This map is truly a cooperative map when you solve it the "intended" way. We weren't looking for exploits, and only accidentally found one (a way to portal from room 1 to room 2, which only saved walking time). We must have found four different ways to solve the 1-2-3 puzzle. We had to try that many because our execution is so clumsy we couldn't beat the clock, so we'd try to find a quicker route.
While expert players might be able to pick this thing apart, we mere mortals were just having fun. We give it 5/5.
[spoiler]My YouTube Channel: Please subscribe!
My Steam Workshop Check out my collections for some good maps
Basic Mod for playing .vpk files Needs to be updated for dlc2, but still works[/spoiler]
I love this way 
...it's shown in our gameplay. 
That's fine by me - from my point of view it can only improve the map.
As promised: Here we go!!! 
Glitchviewing:
YNTU4o2qSvE
Special thanks to PortalCombat for his help and ideas! 
While expert players might be able to pick this thing apart, we mere mortals were just having fun. We give it 5/5.
This is the same for my friend and I. We really enjoyed the co-op (upstairs/downstairs) aspect of this map! Thanks! Looking forward to your next one!
To KennKong and Redunzl: I'm pleased you experimented in the 1-2-3 puzzle - that chamber is meant to be a little sandboxy as you described. I'm also glad that the timer wasn't too restrictive, but still created pressure.
To BlumCoLe and PortalCombat: Thanks for this latest video, you managed to find number of ways to peel apart the map! I should have a revision that prevents your crafty techniques uploaded this evening. EDIT: Revision 3 is now uploaded.
To oMavericko and your partner: What do you mean by the 'co-op (upstairs/downstairs) aspect'? The way that the players are forced to be separated?
Co-operative: Lightspeed Upstairs Downstairs
Excellent map. Me & my coop partner stopped playing the first version after all the exploits becoming obvious, but now that it's revised we had a lot of fun.
Only part I thought of as falling short is the final puzzle. In a map that is so open-ended just about every portal surface you shoot the laser through to finish it feels like you're exploiting something.
To be honest I would say: either abandon that part or make it have a clearer way of reaching the goal(that doesn't have to mean giving away the solution).
5/5, congrats on making a map that is varied, has a lot of typical co-op moments and looks fantastic!
You solved the laser puzzle as I intended. I take your point it feeling 'exploit-y' though, I'll have to have a think about that one.
Co-operative: Lightspeed Upstairs Downstairs
Haha why don't you make this the intended solution?
Anyways great map, we solved everything as intended until that last part! Really beautiful map, 5/5!
Great map! We felt the map would have (mostly) fit in with retail quite well.
However, there is at least one unintended solution still left.
Here is our run. It was supposed to be a blind run but my wifi disconnected a minute or two into the 3rd chamber. We had already spent about 15 minutes before this video going from puzzle 1 to 3. After that it is blind.
Puzzle 2: I am sure that we do not have the intended solution.
Puzzle 3: Perhaps we have the intended solution? We did it 1-2-3. We were not sure if one player was supposed to be able to push both #3 buttons, but I was able to.
Puzzle 4: This should be the intended solution.
Sorry for not having remote_view up, I play with it permanently up but I guess that data is not available during demo playback? I couldn't figure out how to view it after the fact with a demo.